How To Use Broken Link Building For SEO | An Easy Win

You know the feeling. You’re deep in a research rabbit hole, you click a link that promises the exact answer… and 404 Not Found. It’s frustrating. A digital dead end. Most people sigh, hit the “back” button, and try again. But for an SEO? That 404 page isn’t a problem. It’s an invitation. It’s a golden opportunity.

This whole process—finding digital dead ends and turning them into highways that point to your website—is called broken link building. It’s one of the most effective, evergreen strategies in our toolkit. Now, it does require some detective work, but it’s also one of the smartest, most helpful ways to earn high-quality backlinks. We’re not talking about spammy tricks here. It’s about being genuinely helpful. You’re fixing someone’s website. In exchange, you get a powerful vote of confidence for your own site.

This guide is your complete playbook. We’ll walk through how to use broken link building for SEO, step-by-step. We’ll cover the tools, the tactics, the outreach, and the real-life stories that make the difference between a successful campaign and a failed one.

More in Off-Page SEO & Link Building Category

Guest Blogging Strategy For SEO

Beginner’s Guide To Building Backlinks

Key Takeaways

Before we get into the weeds, here’s the 30,000-foot view:

• What it is: You find web pages that are linking to a dead page (that dreaded 404 error).
• What you do: You email that site’s owner, politely point out the dead link, and suggest your own (awesome) content as a replacement.
• Why it works: You help the webmaster fix their site (which is good for their users and their SEO), and you get a high-quality, relevant backlink.
• The mindset: Be helpful first. Your main goal is to provide value. The link is just the reward for doing that.
• The catch: The idea is simple. The work takes persistence. Success rates can be low, but one “win” from a major site can change the game.

So, What’s This “Broken Link Building” Everyone Talks About?

When you strip it all down, the idea is beautifully simple. It’s just a three-step dance:

1. Prospect: First, you hunt for relevant websites in your niche that have broken outbound links. These are links pointing to other sites that are now dead.
2. Create: Next, you make sure you have a fantastic piece of content on your site that would be a perfect replacement for that dead link.
3. Reach Out: Finally, you send a personalized, friendly email to the site owner, give them a heads-up about the broken link, and offer your content as a helpful substitute.

That’s really it. Think of yourself as a helpful Internet janitor. You’re just tidying up the web, one dead link at a time, and getting rewarded for your efforts.

But why does this work so much better than just cold-emailing someone and asking, “Hey, can you link to my stuff?”

Simple. You’re not asking for a favor. You’re offering one.

You’re showing up with a solution, not a request. You’ve spotted a real problem on their website—a link sending their visitors to a dead end—and you’ve already got a perfect, easy fix. That one simple shift in framing changes the entire dynamic. You’re not a spammer. You’re a colleague.

Why Is This Still One of My Go-To SEO Strategies?

I’ll be honest. I’ve been in the SEO game for a long time. I’ve watched strategies come and go. I’ve seen “hacks” blow up and then get obliterated by a single Google update.

Broken link building? It has never failed me. It works just as well today as it did a decade ago. The reason is that it aligns perfectly with Google’s own goals. Google wants to give users the best possible experience, and dead links are a terrible experience. When you fix them, you’re actively helping the webmaster, the user, and Google. It’s a win-win-win.

I remember my first real “aha!” moment with this. I was just starting out, probably spending way too much time reading a major marketing blog. I clicked on a “recommended resource” link in one of their pillar articles, and… 404.

My heart actually sped up.

This wasn’t just any 404. It was on an article that I knew got thousands of visits a month, from a site with a massive domain authority. I checked that dead link in Ahrefs and saw it had dozens of other high-quality sites linking to it. It was like finding a buried treasure map. I spent the next three days writing the best possible replacement article I could. I sent my email, held my breath, and 24 hours later? I got a “Wow, thank you so much! Link is updated.”

I didn’t just get one link. I got a link from that authority blog, and I now had a new list of prospects (everyone else linking to that same dead page) I could reach out to.

That’s when it clicked. This isn’t just a link-building tactic. It’s a way to build relationships and establish your authority, all by being genuinely helpful.

Do I Really Need Expensive Tools for This?

Alright, let’s talk logistics. Can you do this for free? Technically, yes. But I’ll be blunt: it’s a painful, slow-motion grind.

The free method involves:

1. Manually finding relevant sites (like resource pages or blogrolls).
2. Installing a browser extension like “Check My Links.”
3. Manually clicking the extension on every single page you visit to scan for 404s.

It works. But it’s painfully slow.

If you’re serious about using broken link building for SEO, investing in a proper toolkit will 100x your efficiency. You don’t need everything, but a couple of key tools will change the game.

What Are the “Must-Have” Tools for Serious BLB?

Think of these as your metal detectors for finding that buried treasure. You could just dig randomly with a shovel, but why would you?

• Ahrefs: This is the king. Its “Backlink Profile” and “Content Explorer” features are the core of my BLB workflow. The ability to plug in a competitor’s site and instantly see a report of all their “Broken Backlinks” is worth the price of admission alone. It turns hours of manual prospecting into about 10 seconds of clicking.
• Semrush: A very powerful alternative to Ahrefs. Its Backlink Analytics tool also has a feature to find broken links, and it’s fantastic for finding high-quality prospects. Many pros use both, but one or the other is essential.
• Screaming Frog SEO Spider: This is a different kind of tool. It’s a desktop-based crawler. You point it at a specific website (like a big university resource page), and it will crawl every single link on that site. You can then easily filter its report for “External 404” errors. This is my secret weapon for finding broken links on a specific target site.

What About Tools for Finding Contact Info?

This is the other half of the battle. You can find the best broken link in the world, but it’s useless if you send your email to info@company.com and it vanishes into a black hole.

You need to find the right person. This is usually a “Content Manager,” “Digital Marketing Manager,” “Editor,” or the author of that specific blog post.

• Hunter.io / Snov.io: These are email-finding tools. They integrate with your browser and can help you find the email addresses associated with a specific domain. They’re not 100% accurate, but they’re a great starting point.
• Good Old-Fashioned Google: Don’t underestimate this. I often use searches like [Site Name] content manager site:linkedin.com to find the person’s name, and then I’ll use a tool like Hunter to “guess” their email format (e.g., firstname.lastname@domain.com).
• Twitter: Seriously. Find the author of the article on Twitter. Their DMs might be open, or you can often find their personal website (which might have a contact form) in their bio.

Your toolkit is your foundation. A good tool doesn’t just save you time—it uncovers opportunities you would never have found on your own.

Where Do I Even Begin Looking for Dead Links?

Okay, you’ve got your tools, and you’re ready to hunt. But where do you even start? The Internet is a big place.

Your prospecting method will make or break your success. You need a system. I break my whole process down into two main “hunting grounds.”

How Can I “Steal” My Competitor’s Broken Backlinks?

This is the most popular and, often, the most fruitful method. It’s delightfully ruthless.

The logic is simple. Your competitors have been building links for years. Over time, some of their pages have inevitably been deleted, moved, or renamed. The sites that used to link to those pages? They’re now linking to a 404.

You are going to find those sites and give them your link instead.

Here’s the step-by-step in Ahrefs (Semrush has a similar workflow):

1. Identify Your Competitors: Grab a list of 5-10 sites that you compete with on the search results pages.
2. Plug Them In: Enter one competitor’s domain into Ahrefs’ “Site Explorer.”
3. Find the Gold: In the left-hand menu, go to Backlink Profile > Broken.
4. Analyze: Ahrefs will instantly generate a report of every single website that is currently linking to a dead page on your competitor’s site.

This. Is. A. Goldmine.

You get a pre-vetted list of prospects. You know exactly what topic they link to (you can see the dead page’s URL and anchor text). You know they’re already linking to your competitor. This isn’t a cold lead. It’s a warm one. They’ve already shown they’re willing to link to the type of content you have.

Your job is to just offer them a working version of that content.

Can I Find Broken Links on Specific, High-Authority Sites?

Yes, and this is the “sniper” approach, while the competitor method is the “shotgun” approach. This is my favorite method for landing those .EDU and .GOV links that SEOs dream about.

The targets here are “resource pages.” These are pages that university websites, government organizations, and major industry blogs create to be helpful. They are curated lists of the “Best Links for [Topic].”

Think: lib.stanford.edu/resources/best-psychology-links or city.gov/small-business-resources.

These pages are often old. They were built years ago and are not always updated regularly. This makes them perfect hunting grounds for link rot.

Here’s how you find them:

1. Use Google Search Operators: Go to Google and use advanced search queries to find these pages. These are your magic wands.
   • site:.edu "your keyword" + "resources"
   • site:.gov "your keyword" + "links"
   • inurl:links "your keyword"
   • "best resources for" + "your keyword"
2. Gather Your Targets: Open up 10-20 of these resource pages in new tabs. They’ll probably look a bit dated. That’s good.
3. Run Your Scan: This is where the free “Check My Links” extension shines. On each resource page, click the extension icon. It will crawl all the links on that one page and highlight all the 404s in red.
4. Qualify: Just because it’s broken doesn’t mean it’s an opportunity. You need to look at the anchor text and the dead URL to understand what that link was about. If you have a resource that is a perfect, 1-to-1 replacement, you’ve found a prime opportunity.

This method takes more patience, no doubt. But the payoff? It’s enormous. A single link from a major university resource page carries more weight than dozens of low-quality blog links.

Is There a Way to Find 404s on an Entire Website at Once?

This is the advanced technique. Let’s say you’ve found a major, high-authority blog in your niche. You know they must have some broken outbound links, but running “Check My Links” on every single one of their 1,000+ blog posts would take you a year.

This is where you use Screaming Frog.

1. Configure: Open Screaming Frog. Go to Configuration > Spider > Crawl. Make sure you have “Check External Links” ticked.
2. Crawl: Enter the homepage of your target site (e.g., bigindustryblog.com) and hit “Start.”
3. Wait: Go get a coffee. This will take a while, as it’s crawling their entire site.
4. Filter: When it’s done, go to the External tab. In the “Filter” dropdown, select Client Error (4xx).
5. Analyze: Screaming Frog will now show you a list of every single broken outbound link on their entire site. The report will show you (1) the dead link itself (the 404) and (2) the “Inlinks” tab at the bottom will show you which page on their site contains that broken link.

You’re now, essentially, doing a free site audit for them. You might find 5, 10, or even 20 broken links across their site. This makes your outreach email (which we’re getting to next) incredibly powerful. You’re not just pointing out one error; you’re helping them clean up their entire site.

I Found a Broken Link… Now What Do I Replace It With?

This is the step where so many people fail. They find a broken link, and they try to shoehorn in their homepage or a completely irrelevant product page.

This will never work.

Your replacement content MUST match the intent of the original, dead link. If the broken link was “A 10-Step Guide to Potty Training a Puppy,” you can’t just suggest your article on “The Best Dog Food Brands.” It’s not helpful. It’s just a transparent, selfish request.

You have two options:

Option 1: You Already Have a Perfect Match This is the dream. You find a broken link to “Guide to Sustainable Pet Food,” and you just happen to have your own “Ultimate Guide to Eco-Friendly Pet Food.” In this case, you’re golden. Move straight to outreach.

Option 2: You Need to Create the Content (The Skyscraper Method) This is where the real work—and the real genius—of this whole strategy lies. Let’s say you find that broken “Guide to Sustainable Pet Food” link, but you don’t have a matching article.

What do you do?

1. Go to the Wayback Machine: Go to archive.org and plug in the dead URL.
2. See What It Was: The Wayback Machine will often have a saved copy of the old, dead page. Now you can see exactly what content that webmaster originally thought was worthy of a link.
3. Make Something 10x Better: This is your mission. Don’t just copy the old article. Create the new definitive guide. Make it more detailed, add better graphics, include expert quotes, and update any old statistics.
4. Publish It: Put this new, incredible resource on your own site.

Now, when you do your outreach, your email is unstoppable. You can literally say, “Hey, I noticed your link to [Old Guide] was broken. I actually used to love that article, so I created a new, updated version that covers all the same points and adds [X, Y, and Z]. Thought it might be a good replacement!”

That’s how you turn a simple link-building tactic into a powerful authority-building machine.

Why Do All My Outreach Emails Get Ignored?

Okay, let’s talk about the most delicate part of the process: the outreach. This is where all your hard work pays off… or falls flat.

I have to tell you a cringey story from my early days.

When I first started, I thought this was just a numbers game. I built a list of 500 prospects. I wrote a terrible, generic email template. It was something like:

“Subject: LINK OPPORTUNITY

Dear Webmaster,

I was browsing your site and I saw you have a broken link. My site, [MySite], is a great resource in the [Niche] space. I think a link to my site would be very valuable for your users.

Please let me know when you have added the link.

sincerely, A desperate, young me”

I sent 500 of these. My response rate was 0%. Literally zero. Not even a “no, thank you.” Just… crickets.

I felt like a total failure. I’d wasted weeks. I learned a hard lesson that day: You are emailing a person, not a website.

That “webmaster” is a busy content manager, a stressed-out business owner, or a passionate blogger. They get 50 spammy link requests a day. Your generic template doesn’t just get ignored; it gets you marked as spam.

From that day on, I vowed to never send an email I wouldn’t be proud to receive myself.

What’s the Anatomy of a Perfect Broken Link Email?

Your email needs to be three things: Personal, Helpful, and Short.

Here is the exact anatomy I stick to.

• The Subject Line (Be Clear and Human):
  • Bad: Link Request or SEO Partnership
  • Good: A broken link on your [Page Name] page
  • Even Better: Quick heads-up about your site
  • My Favorite: Found a 404 on your [Topic] article
• The Opener (The 2-Sentence Personalization):
  • This is non-negotiable. You must prove you’ve actually read their site.
  • “Hi [Name],
  • I was just reading your excellent guide to [Article Topic]. That tip about [Specific Thing You Liked] was genuinely brilliant.”
  • This first two lines are what stop their thumb from hitting “Delete.”
• The “Find” (The Helpful Bit):
  • Get straight to the point.
  • “As I was reading, I clicked on your link to [Name of Dead Resource], and it seems the page is no longer there (it’s loading a 404 error).”
  • Pro Tip: Give them the exact anchor text and the dead URL so they don’t have to hunt for it. Make it easy for them.
• The “Fix” (The Casual Suggestion):
  • This is the pivot. Don’t be pushy.
  • “I know how annoying those can be to fix. If you’re looking for a replacement, I actually just published a detailed guide on that exact topic: [Your Article Title].”
  • Optional but powerful: “It’s been updated for [Current Year] and includes [X, Y, and Z].”
• The Close (The No-Pressure Sign-off):
  • This is key to not sounding like a selfish marketer.
  • “Hope this helps! Either way, keep up the amazing work on the blog.
  • Best,
  • [Your Name]”

See the difference? You’re not demanding a thing. You’re offering help. And by the way, you happen to have a resource if they need it. It’s a soft pitch, wrapped in a blanket of genuine helpfulness.

Can You Show Me a Real-World Example That Worked?

I’ll give you a perfect one. I was working with a client in the sustainable pet food space. A very competitive niche. We were desperate for a high-authority link.

Using the “sniper” method, I was targeting .edu resource pages. I found a Student Wellness resource page on a major university’s website. It was a list of “resources for healthy living.” Tucked away at the bottom was a dead link to an old article called “Choosing Healthy Food for Your Pet.”

Bingo.

The page was managed by the “Director of Student Life.” I found her name and email address. Here is the exact email I sent, (names and domains changed, of course).

Subject: Broken link on your Student Wellness page

Body:

Hi Dr. Evans,

My name is [My Name], and I was just looking at your “Wellness Resources” page (a fantastic list for students!).

I just wanted to give you a quick heads-up that the link you have for “Choosing Healthy Food for Your Pet” seems to be broken—it’s leading to a 404 Not Found error.

My team and I just published a comprehensive guide on sustainable and healthy pet food options, which I thought might make a good replacement. It covers ingredients, ethical sourcing, and budget-friendly choices for students.

Here’s our guide: [Link to Client's Article]

No pressure at all, but thought it might save you the time of hunting for a new link! It’s a great page, and I hope this helps.

Best, [My Name]

Two days later, I got this response:

“Hi [My Name],

You are a lifesaver! Thank you so much for pointing this out, I’ve been meaning to update that page for ages. This new guide is perfect. I’ve just updated the link.

Thanks again, Dr. Evans”

Boom. A .edu backlink from a high-authority domain. The client was ecstatic. This one link visibly moved the needle on their rankings. It was a “win” that came not from a trick, but from being polite, respectful, and helpful.

This is the kind of high-quality, relevant page that works perfectly for this method. For example, look at this student wellness resource list from Georgetown University’s Law Library—it’s a perfect example of a high-authority page filled with links that could, over time, break and create opportunities.

What’s the Right Way to Follow Up (Without Being Annoying)?

This is a tough one. People are busy. Your perfectly crafted email might have just landed at a bad time.

My rule is simple: One follow-up. That’s it.

Wait 5-7 business days. If you haven’t heard back, reply to your original email (so they have the context) with something short and sweet.

“Hi [Name],

Just wanted to follow up on this in case it got buried in your inbox.

No worries if you’re busy, just thought the heads-up about the broken link might be helpful!

Best, [My Name]”

That’s it. It’s gentle, it’s not accusatory, and it bumps you to the top of their inbox one last time. If they don’t respond to this, they’re either not interested or they’re too busy. Delete them from your list and move on. Harassing them will only get your domain blacklisted.

They Said Yes! What Do I Do Now?

First, do a happy dance.

Second, send a “thank you” email. Immediately.

“Hi [Name],

That’s fantastic! Thank you so much, I really appreciate you adding the link.

I’m sharing your article with my [Twitter/LinkedIn] audience now.

Have a great rest of your week!

Best, [My Name]”

And then actually go share their article. This simple act transforms the transaction into a relationship. You’ve just made a contact at a high-authority site. They now view you as a helpful, collaborative person. This is how you build a real network, which is infinitely more valuable than a single link.

They Ignored Me or Said No. Did I Fail?

Absolutely not. Welcome to link building.

You need to understand this: for any link-building campaign, a 5-10% success rate is considered a smashing success.

That means 90-95% of your emails will be ignored, rejected, or lost to the void.

This is not failure. This is just the cost of doing business. This is why your prospecting list needs to be long. This is why you can’t get emotionally attached to any single “perfect” opportunity.

The people who fail at broken link building aren’t the ones who get told “no.” They’re the ones who give up after 20 “no’s” and never get to that first, game-changing “yes.”

Embrace the rejection. It means you’re in the game.

Is Broken Link Building Really an “Easy Win”?

I’ll close with this. The title of this article calls it an “easy win.” And in the world of SEO… it kinda is.

But “easy” in SEO never means “effortless.”

• Is it easier than guest posting on 50 blogs? Yes.
• Is it easier than creating a viral-level infographic that gets 1,000 links overnight? Absolutely.
• Is it easier than trying to beg a journalist at a major news site to link to your e-commerce store? Infinitely.

It’s an “easy win” because the logic is undeniable. You are helping someone solve a real problem. It’s one of the few link-building strategies that isn’t a zero-sum game. Everyone wins. The webmaster gets a fixed site. Their users get a better experience. And you get a powerful, relevant, earned backlink.

It takes work. It takes detective skills. It takes persistence. No doubt. But it’s a process you can follow. It’s a system you can build. And it’s a strategy that, unlike so many others, will always work.

So go. Start hunting. Those 404s aren’t dead ends. They’re just opportunities waiting for someone helpful enough to find them.

FAQ